Skip to content
“First in Revolution”

POLICE LOG: Resident reports $9,900 computer scam, missing $5,000 diamond stud

Marblehead Police Department seal

Table of Contents

Oct. 19

1:16 p.m. — Officer Adam Mastrangelo was dispatched to a public beach parking lot on Ocean Avenue to meet with a town parks and recreation representative, who had called about boats and trailers left in the lot. When he arrived, Mastrangelo saw multiple boats and empty trailers parked there, and the representative asked that all of them be moved out of the lot as soon as possible. With help from dispatchers, police reached many of the boat owners and told them they would need to remove their boats and trailers. Mastrangelo also found three empty trailers with no license plates or any other identification. He requested tows for those three from a supervising lieutenant, who approved them, and a towing company arrived shortly afterward and hauled the trailers out of the lot. The report lists the call as assistance to a citizen, with no crime involved.

Oct. 20

8:46 a.m. — Officer Douglas Mills was dispatched to Ocean Avenue to take a report of alleged harassment by a neighbor. The caller, a resident who walks the neighborhood daily, told Mills he had been dealing with ongoing harassment from a man who lives on Nanepashemet Street. The resident said that in August the man allegedly tripped him as he walked by, then denied doing so at the time; the resident said he did not report it then, chose instead to avoid the man and changed his walking route, though living in the same neighborhood meant he could not avoid him entirely. He said that when he sees the man coming, he stops and yields the right of way to avoid a confrontation, and that after the tripping the man allegedly shouldered him on purpose while passing. That morning, the resident said, he encountered the man again on Ocean Avenue near Nanepashemet Street while walking a puppy he is training; the puppy pulled and lunged toward the man, but the resident said he held the leash firmly and that neither he nor the dog made contact. While he held the puppy back, the man allegedly yelled obscenities, told him he was “supposed to walk the other way,” used an expletive in calling him a foreigner and told him to go back to wherever he came from. The resident said he wanted advice and a record of the encounter. Mills explained how harassment prevention orders work and how to apply for one, suggested he cross the street rather than engage if he saw the man, and offered to speak with the man; the resident declined, saying he wanted only documentation for now. The next morning, about 9:10 a.m., the resident called Mills and said he had changed his mind. Mills went to the man’s home on Nanepashemet Street and got no answer at the door, then left a voicemail at a phone number dispatchers located. About 2:30 p.m., Mills reached the man by phone. The man acknowledged using some choice language but denied calling the resident a foreigner, saying he had asked him “what planet are you from” because he felt the resident was walking on the wrong side of the road. He said he knew about the August encounter but never touched the resident, who he said simply tripped, and that he even offered to help him up and was told, profanely, to go away. He told Mills the resident is the one who starts their interactions. Mills said he had advised the resident to avoid contact and that it would be best if the man did the same, and the man agreed not to initiate any further contact.

11:56 a.m. — Officer Charles Sweeney was dispatched to an apartment building on State Street for a report of a dispute between neighbors. He was met by a downstairs resident and a woman who was with her, and the second woman told Sweeney that the tenant of an upstairs unit had just been on the resident’s deck, upset and allegedly throwing furniture around. The woman said she went outside and confronted the tenant, the argument escalated and she called police. Sweeney went upstairs and spoke with the tenant, who said she had moved in within the past month and was upset about the furniture on the deck. She showed Sweeney that her unit and the resident’s share a deck and a staircase attached to both apartments, and said the furniture made it hard for her to get by, so she grew frustrated and moved it. Sweeney told the tenant to contact the building owner to sort out who is allowed to use the deck and whether the leases address it, and told her not to touch her neighbor’s porch furniture again. The tenant also showed him a storage area in the building and said she was unhappy that people had been moving her belongings; Sweeney advised her to take that up with the building owner as well. Before clearing, he told the resident and the tenant to stay away from each other and to call if more problems arose. When Sweeney got back to the station, the resident’s son was waiting with home security camera footage that, according to the report, shows the tenant visibly upset and aggressively trying to flip a table over and move it, along with footage of the tenant allegedly accosting the second woman through a sliding door. Sweeney told the son he had spoken with everyone involved, that the tenant had been told to leave the deck furniture alone and that the two households needed to get the rules for the porch from the building owner. He also explained how to obtain a harassment prevention order and asked that any further incidents be reported. Sweeney attached the footage to the report, which lists no crime involved.

1:33 p.m. — Officer Charles Sweeney was dispatched to the police station lobby to speak with a pedestrian who reported being struck by a vehicle earlier that day in a bank parking lot on Pleasant Street. The pedestrian told Sweeney that about 9:30 a.m. she was walking through the lot when a vehicle allegedly backed into her. Part of the narrative that follows was redacted from the public copy of the report. The pedestrian was able to photograph the vehicle, a gray 2022 Acura MDX, and give a description of the driver, and she told Sweeney she had confirmed that the vehicle’s registered owner was the person driving it. Sweeney told her he would follow up. After she left the station, he contacted a vice president of the bank, who said he could pull up video footage of the morning’s incident and would get back to Sweeney the next morning once he was at work. The report, which lists no crime involved, ends with a note that more information is to follow.

4:38 p.m. — Officer Tyler Bates was dispatched to Jersey Street for a report of alleged identity theft. A resident told Bates she had received two letters in the mail over the previous couple of days: one from Walmart MoneyCard containing a credit card and instructions for activating it, and another from Comenity Capital Bank stating that her recent application for a Lexus Pursuits Visa account had been declined. The resident said she had not applied for either account and believed she was the victim of identity theft. She told Bates she had begun working with the credit bureaus to freeze her account and alert them to the alleged fraud, and that she had also spotted a Tire Rack transaction she did not make. Bates documented her account; the report lists no crime involved.

Oct. 21

1:40 p.m. — Officer Christian Hennigar responded to a business on Market Square to take a report of alleged fraud. The caller told Hennigar he had received mail from Capital One stating that he owed a balance of $7,438.15, even though he does not use Capital One. He said he had already called the company to report the alleged fraudulent activity and had contacted his own bank about any potential fraud, and that he was not out any money at that point. Copies of the mail were attached to the report. Hennigar told the caller his statements would be documented and that a copy of the report would be available; the report lists no crime involved.

Oct. 22

11:56 p.m. — Officer Nicholas Fratini met at the police station with a woman who reported that her jacket, with her Mazda car keys in it, had allegedly been taken from a bar on Pleasant Street earlier that night. She told Fratini that when she went to leave, the jacket was gone, and that the bar’s owner showed her video footage of another woman allegedly taking it. Other patrons identified the woman in the video, and Fratini wrote that he was also able to identify her from the footage. According to the report, the video shows her inspecting the jacket and walking away, then returning a short time later with a man, after which the jacket is taken off its hook and carried out. Fratini reached the woman by phone, and she said she did not have the jacket and that it was “unfortunate that girl lost her jacket and keys.” He made several unsuccessful attempts to reach the man. About 1:40 a.m., Fratini spoke with the woman by phone again, and she said she had contacted the man, that he could not find the jacket or keys and that she had searched her own home several times without finding them either. About 7:35 a.m., the jacket’s owner told Fratini by phone that she wanted charges filed if her belongings were not returned, and at about 7:40 a.m. he left the woman a voicemail saying he would proceed with charges if the jacket and keys were not back by a midnight deadline. According to the report, all of the property was returned to its owner at some point Oct. 24. The department lists the case, classified as an alleged larceny under $1,200, as open.

Oct. 23

1:18 a.m. — Officer Nicholas Michaud was dispatched to Warren Road for a report of an allegedly stolen vehicle. The caller, a resident, told Michaud he had received a stolen-vehicle alert from OnStar about 12:23 a.m. and went outside to find his truck gone. During their conversation, the resident acknowledged that he had been supposed to turn the vehicle in about two months earlier but had not had the chance, and he said he did not know whether it had been repossessed. Dispatchers said they had received no notification of any repossession. Part of the narrative was redacted from the public copy of the report. Michaud advised the resident to contact the leasing company in the morning to confirm whether it had taken the truck back, and to contact police if it had not. The report lists no crime involved.

Oct. 24

1:56 p.m. — Officer Brandon Boutilier took a report in the police station lobby from a Washington Street resident about an alleged confrontation with her next-door neighbor Oct. 20. The resident told Boutilier she keeps a small garden space between her house and the sidewalk, where she sometimes sets out items for people to take for free. She said that on Oct. 20 the neighbor was upset because a car had pulled into his driveway so someone could grab an item she had put out, and that he allegedly shouted at her that she needed to stop putting things out in her garden or he would throw them into the street. The resident said the exchange upset her and that she wanted it documented in case anything similar happens again, to help build a case for a harassment prevention order. Boutilier told her he would document the incident and advised her to report any future interactions. The report lists no crime involved.

2:04 p.m. — Officer Christian Hennigar responded to the police station to speak with an Edgemere Road resident about a set of allegedly stolen golf clubs, reaching her first by phone. The resident said she had leaned the clubs against a rock wall in her front yard, left home for a short time and found them gone when she returned. She also told Hennigar that a neighbor had held an estate sale a few days earlier and that she was not sure whether someone had taken her clubs by mistake. Hennigar asked whether she could come to the station to complete a property loss form, and she did, valuing the clubs at between $500 and $800. The resident said she had posted about the clubs on Facebook and would let police know of any updates. The department lists the case, classified as an alleged larceny under $1,200, as open.

Oct. 26

12:52 p.m. — Officer Adam Mastrangelo was dispatched to the police station lobby to take a report of alleged fraud from an Endicott Avenue resident. The resident told Mastrangelo that on Oct. 14 he was scrolling through Facebook when he clicked a link and his computer began flashing with a message saying it had been taken over. The website allegedly displayed a phone number for Microsoft, which he called, and after receiving information from the man who answered, he gave that man remote access to his computer. The resident said he ultimately gave the man $9,900 from his bank account. Mastrangelo advised him to close the account, which the resident had already done; block all phone numbers he did not recognize; have his computer and cellphone cleaned; and report the matter to the credit agencies. The report classifies the case as an alleged felony larceny of more than $250 from a person 60 or older or with a disability, and Mastrangelo wrote that it will be forwarded to the department’s Criminal Investigation Division. The department lists the case as open.

1:08 p.m. — Officer Douglas Mills was dispatched to the police station lobby to take a report of missing jewelry from a Bubier Road resident. The resident told Mills she had lost one stud from a pair of custom diamond earrings, a diamond set in 14-karat yellow gold that she valued at about $5,000 on a lost property form attached to the report. She said the earring went missing sometime around Sept. 18 and that she needed a police report for her insurance. Mills told her he would document what she told him; the report lists no crime involved.

4:37 p.m. — Officer Dennis DeFelice met at the police station with a Mohawk Road resident who reported that his wife had allegedly been the victim of identity fraud. The resident told DeFelice he had received a Verizon bill for a cellphone the couple does not have, said his wife has no Verizon account and said he believes the bill is fraudulent. He told DeFelice he had contacted Verizon, which will investigate the matter on its end. DeFelice advised him on the steps to resolve the issue through the Federal Trade Commission, the state’s official website and the credit bureaus. The department lists the case, classified as alleged identity fraud, as open.

5:26 p.m. — Officer Robert Picariello was dispatched to a shopping plaza parking lot on Pleasant Street for a report of a child allegedly left alone in a vehicle. The caller had told dispatchers that the parent had already returned and driven away but that she still wanted to speak with an officer. She told Picariello she had noticed a child about 2 years old in the back of a blue Ford pickup, with no one else in the truck. When she asked the boy whether he was all right, he motioned toward a nearby market and mentioned his father. The father then returned to the truck and, according to the caller, became very upset that she was questioning him about why he had left the child before driving off. The caller estimated that the father had been away from the truck for a couple of moments. The report lists no crime involved.

Oct. 27

11:14 a.m. — Officer Christian Hennigar responded to the police station to take a report of alleged vehicle damage. The resident who reported it told Hennigar she was driving on Prospect Street when she came upon a tree company crew cutting down a tree. She said that despite branches in the roadway, she was waved through and given the go-ahead to drive past the job site, and that as she did, the branches brushed against her vehicle and allegedly left streaks along its left side. According to the report, the resident was visibly upset because she had told the workers she could not get by without hitting the branches. Hennigar told her he would document the incident; the report lists no crime involved.

12:36 p.m. — Officer Adam Mastrangelo was dispatched to McKinley Road on a report of past property damage. The resident there told Mastrangelo that on Oct. 19 the windshield of his truck, which was parked in front of his house, was allegedly damaged, leaving a large crack that, according to the report, was consistent with a hard object being thrown at it or struck by hand. Mastrangelo could not inspect that damage because the resident had already had the truck repaired, though the resident provided a photo. The resident also said that sometime between 11:30 a.m. Oct. 24 and 11:30 p.m. Oct. 25, a front window of his home was allegedly damaged, and he provided photos of that as well. Mastrangelo noted in the report that a large tree stands in front of the window, which would make it very difficult for an object thrown from the street to strike it. The resident said no landscapers or other workers had been at the house recently and that he was not at odds with anyone. Part of the narrative was redacted from the public copy of the report. Mastrangelo advised the resident to call police if anything else happens. The department lists the case, which includes two counts of alleged malicious destruction of property valued under $1,200, as open.

Oct. 28

1:47 a.m. — Officer Samuel Rizos was dispatched to Lincoln Park for a neighbor complaint. The caller told Rizos that a short time earlier, while he was in his kitchen, a neighbor arrived home and allegedly parked so that the vehicle’s headlights shone through his kitchen window, and that after the headlights went off he noticed a flashlight outside that appeared as though it could have been pointed toward his home. He said he had recently had a fence repaired through the association and that one of his neighbors believes he is at fault for something to do with the fence. He pointed out the neighbor’s home, two doors down, and a black sport utility vehicle parked on the street alongside his residence, which he said was the vehicle whose headlights had shone into his window. Rizos said he would try to reach the neighbor for her side of the story, and as the caller walked back inside, the neighbor came outside. According to the report, she was immediately very vocal about her displeasure with the caller and said he was the problem in the dispute and in the association in general. She told Rizos that for some reason he does not like that she comes home late, walks her dog and keeps a light on her back deck, explaining that she works in an emergency room, gets home late some nights and walks her dog. She said the matter was not a police issue and apologized that police had been called. Rizos advised her to avoid contact with the caller, to call police if problems continue and to contact the association. The report lists no crime involved.

11:28 a.m. — Officer Douglas Mills was dispatched to the police station to speak with an Alden Road resident about an alleged scam phone call. The resident told Mills she received a call from someone claiming to represent Citibank, who said someone had opened a credit card in her name. She said she recognized the call as a scam and gave the callers no information, though they already had part of her Social Security number without her providing it. She told Mills she had checked with her bank and was not out any money, and that she had checked and frozen her credit. She said she wanted police to be aware of the alleged scam in case anything further came of it. The department lists the case, classified as an alleged attempt to commit a crime, as open.

8:35 p.m. — Officer Tyler Bates and a second officer were dispatched to Hawkes Street for a neighbor dispute. The caller told the officers that the man who lives in the apartment below hers had allegedly just been “banging on the walls” of his apartment, and said the two have an ongoing dispute. The officers then spoke with the downstairs neighbor, who acknowledged banging on the walls but said he did so because the caller was allegedly stomping on the floor above him. He told them he believes she walks around in clogs, which he said would be against the homeowners association’s rules. The officers told both neighbors the matter, clogs included, would be documented; the report lists no crime involved.

Oct. 29

5:24 p.m. — Officer Tyler Bates was dispatched to Foster Street for a report of someone allegedly breaking into a cottage on a residential property. The homeowner told Bates that about 4 p.m. she found the front door of the cottage open, which struck her as strange right away because she always keeps that door shut and locked. Inside, she said, the bed was slightly unmade and a towel that had been used in the bathroom was hanging on an ottoman. She said she had been in the cottage the previous afternoon and everything was in order then, and she believed someone must have gotten inside and possibly showered and used the bed. According to the report, there was no forced entry, nothing was taken and she was not expecting anyone to be in the cottage. Part of the narrative was redacted from the public copy of the report. The department lists the case, classified as an alleged breaking and entering to commit a misdemeanor, as open.

Oct. 30

12:45 p.m. — Officer Brandon Boutilier took a report by phone from a Farrell Court resident about allegedly stolen prescriptions and mail. The resident told Boutilier she had returned home two days earlier and had called the post office twice because her mailbox was empty despite her long absence. She said she was missing various bills and bank statements, along with other items, that had been mailed to her Oct. 5; part of that list was redacted from the public copy of the report. She said the post office told her the carrier had left her mail in the common-room mailbox designated for her. Boutilier asked whether she had checked with the housing office or her neighbors to see whether anyone had taken the mail; she said she had not contacted the housing office and had not heard anything from her neighbors. Boutilier advised her to call her banks and the other companies involved to explain the situation, and told her a copy of his report would be available if needed. The department lists the case, classified as an alleged felony larceny from a building, as open.

Oct. 31

3:26 a.m. — Officer Samuel Rizos was dispatched to West Shore Drive for a reported larceny. The resident who called told Rizos that her boyfriend had allegedly taken $900 in $100 bills from her purse. She then said the amount might have been $1,020, but that she had bought cigarettes, so it may have been closer to $1,003, and that she was unsure of the exact figure. She said she had gone out with him the night before, Oct. 30, and was sure he took it and that she had not misplaced it. Nothing else was missing from her wallet, she said. The resident told Rizos she had called the boyfriend, who had his mother speak with her, and that he denied taking the money. She said she really needs the money back and would accept a check from his mother or a payment plan. She also told Rizos she has totally lost faith in the department after living on Broughton Road and filing many complaints with no resolution. Part of the narrative was redacted from the public copy of the report. Rizos tried unsuccessfully to reach the boyfriend by phone and briefed a detective sergeant on the matter. The department lists the case, classified as an alleged felony larceny of more than $250, as open.

12:04 p.m. — Officer Adam Mastrangelo was dispatched to the police station lobby to take a report of a wallet that was lost or possibly stolen. The resident told Mastrangelo that about 11:30 a.m. she had been shopping at a market on Atlantic Avenue, and that as she drove away, she received a phone notification from an AirTag tracker in her wallet showing the wallet was still in the market’s parking lot. Realizing it was no longer with her, she turned around and drove back to look for it. She said she feared the wallet fell out while she was loading her vehicle, but she could not find it when she returned, and the tracker had since gone offline and stopped showing a location. Mastrangelo immediately advised her to cancel her credit cards and had her fill out a property loss form, which he forwarded to a detective. He also told her to contact police if any charges appear on her cards or if the tracker comes back online, and to notify the Registry of Motor Vehicles that her license is missing. The report lists no crime involved.

12:07 p.m. — Officer Samuel Rizos, working an overtime day shift, spoke at the police station with a resident who reported that while driving on Waldron Street from Gregory Street earlier that day, she struck a privately owned bush, causing minor damage to the driver’s side of her car. According to the report, she was upset because she alleged that construction in the area had caused her to crash. Rizos told her he would call the construction company and drive through the area himself. A short time later, he drove through without issue. He then called the construction company, which said it has all the proper permits from the town and hires police details when needed, including several for its recent work on Waldron Street; a separate contractor is also doing gas line work along all of Gregory Street, according to the report. The resident later called back to say an auto body shop had quoted her $300 to fix the scratch, and Rizos told her a report would be on file if she wished to submit it to her insurance company. The report lists no crime involved.

Latest