Skip to content
“First in Revolution”

School Committee votes 4-0 to give up Eveleth building

State law requires two-thirds approval at Town Meeting to finish the transfer; members then met privately over a lawsuit that names Superintendent John Robidoux.

Superintendent John Robidoux, in a gray suit and blue tie, sits behind a laptop and nameplate at a library table
Superintendent John Robidoux sits behind his nameplate during the School Committee’s Nov. 19 meeting as members asked questions about the enrollment data he had presented. The Committee later voted 4-0 to transfer the Eveleth School to the Select Board. SCREEN CAPTURE FROM NOV. 19 SCHOOL COMMITTEE MEETING VIDEO

Table of Contents

Get our free local reporting delivered straight to your inbox. No noise, no spam — just clear, independent coverage of Marblehead. Sign up for our once-a-week newsletter.

The School Committee voted 4-0 Thursday to transfer care, custody, management and control of the former Eveleth School at 3 Brook Road to the Select Board, declaring the building no longer needed for school.

The vote, which followed a Facilities Subcommittee recommendation and the superintendent’s own, does not finish the job. State law requires a two-thirds vote of Town Meeting to move such land to another board, and Chair Kate Schmeckpeper said the decision must go before Town Meeting. The Select Board opened the warrant Nov. 18 for the 2027 Annual Town Meeting, set for May 3.

The district’s case rests on money and empty seats. The question arrives months after voters approved a $15 million operating override June 9 to address a $7.7 million fiscal 2027 deficit. Schmeckpeper put the cost of keeping Eveleth at about half a million dollars and said the school budget has been stretched as far as it can go. Minutes of the Committee’s Nov. 5 meeting list a boiler replacement at about $140,000 and a feasibility study at about $250,000, both of which the district forwent. Member Al Williams, who made the motion, said he could not envision the district needing the building for years to come and did not consider it fiscally responsible to hold it, which he called his personal opinion.

Space to spare

Superintendent John Robidoux supplied the arithmetic behind his recommendation: 2,371 students in five schools designed for 3,105, leaving 734 open seats, or a district running at 76 percent of design capacity. Marblehead High School holds 767 students in 1,000 seats; Village School, 486 in 700; Veterans Middle School, 355 in 530; Glover School, 308 in 425. Brown School is the exception, with 455 students in a building designed for 450.

Robidoux said Brown’s five extra students were no concern, though he plans to watch kindergarten enrollment there and at Glover early next year because it could shift classrooms. He also said enrollment projections he has reviewed are flat for about a decade.

Housing could change that, but Schmeckpeper said an artificial intelligence assistant she consulted estimated two new students from one project and seven to 15 from an undecided proposal for the Coffin School site. Robidoux called such projections conjecture until developers present their own formulas. Schmeckpeper added that the space would matter if the state delivers universal pre-kindergarten exclusively through public schools, a change Robidoux said would mean reconfiguring grades, not necessarily redistricting.

Closed doors, other votes

The Committee ended its public agenda with a 4-0 roll-call vote, on a motion by member Henry Gwazda seconded by member Ann-Marie Jordan, to enter executive session with no intention of returning to open session.

Split-screen video frame: the School Committee seated in a library at left, and Chair Kate Schmeckpeper speaking at a table with a laptop and nameplate at right
School Committee Chair Kate Schmeckpeper, at right, calls for a vote during the Nov. 19 meeting, with a wide view of the room at left. The Committee’s votes that night included 4-0 decisions to transfer the Eveleth School and enter executive session. SCREEN CAPTURE FROM NOV. 19 SCHOOL COMMITTEE MEETING VIDEO

The agenda listed three topics. The first is a lawsuit, John Doe and Jane Doe v. John Robidoux, et al., docketed in Essex Superior Court as 2677CV01377. Schmeckpeper declared that an open meeting could harm the Committee’s litigating position. Neither the agenda nor her statement described the claims or identified the plaintiffs beyond their pseudonyms.

The others were bargaining strategy for the Marblehead Education Association’s instructional assistant unit and compliance with Open Meeting Law provisions covering 26 earlier executive sessions, from Dec. 21, 2023, to July 8.

The closed session capped a meeting with other business. Members voted to accept a gift from longtime resident Rick Keller to endow an annual $2,500 scholarship for a senior in the Metropolitan Council for Educational Opportunity program. Keller’s letter offered up to $50,000, with the first award going to a 2027 graduate. The motion, by Jordan and seconded by Gwazda, carried. Williams noted that $2,500 is 5 percent of $50,000, a payout he said the fund could sustain indefinitely.

The Committee also voted 4-0 to approve junior Yifei Chen’s trip to the Barkley Forum speech and debate tournament at Emory University in Atlanta, Jan. 21-24. Chen was a finalist in humorous interpretation there last year, according to her trip packet.

Gwazda separately asked the Policy Subcommittee to draft an e-bike safety policy for school property after a conference presentation, saying riders ages 10 to 13 are most affected. No vote was taken. Robidoux said districts including Danvers have adopted such policies, and Schmeckpeper said the subcommittee will take up the request at its early December meeting.

Eveleth’s next steps

For now, Robidoux said, the district keeps control of the building, and Recreation and Parks has asked to keep using it this winter. The town already uses it for document scanning and storage, according to the Nov. 5 minutes.

Once the transfer is complete, Schmeckpeper said in answer to Gwazda’s question, the Committee will have no further vote on the building’s future and no more of a role than any other resident.

BEFORE YOU GO … Our reporting remains free and open to all. It is sustained by readers who choose to support it — by contributing so that routine, document-based local reporting continues without paywalls or promotional framing. Right now, 133 readers support The Marblehead Independent with monthly or annual contributions.  Click here to become an Independent member.

Latest